Professional OPC
Development Tools

logos

Online Forums

Technical support is provided through Support Forums below. Anybody can view them; you need to Register/Login to our site (see links in upper right corner) in order to Post questions. You do not have to be a licensed user of our product.

Please read Rules for forum posts before reporting your issue or asking a question. OPC Labs team is actively monitoring the forums, and replies as soon as possible. Various technical information can also be found in our Knowledge Base. For your convenience, we have also assembled a Frequently Asked Questions page.

Do not use the Contact page for technical issues.

Data updates missing, and not in the correct order

More
10 Nov 2015 11:15 #3652 by support
Thank you for the information.

I think that the most likely answer is that the server is simply sending values in this order. If you want to verify that, we would need to employ some deeper analysis - for example, make a Wireshark capture of the communication between the client and the server, and then determine where the issue comes from (server side, or client side).

Regarding your code: In general, it is preferable to use the SubscribeMultipleMonitoredItems methods (as opposed to just SubscribeMonitoredItem). The reason for that is that each call requires a roundtrip to the server and making many calls is thus inefficient, The reason why you received "worse" results with SubscribeMultipleMonitoredItems might be in this:

SubscribeMonitoredItem takes as an input the SamplingInterval (which is how often the underlying data source should provide values to the server), and automatically determines the PublishingInterval (which is how often the server should provide values to the client), usually as one half of the SamplingInterval.

SubscribeMultipleMonitoredItems, on the other hand, by default, does not automatically determine the PublishingInterval - it uses whatever value it finds in the parameters, and the default is 1000 ms. This is probably no good if your SamplingRate is e.g. 1000 ms as well. I suggest that you use the SubscribeMultipleMonitoredItems, but in addition, set the monitoredItemArguments.SubscriptionParameters.PublishingInterval to one half of the SamplingInterval or less.


Best regards

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Nov 2015 14:01 #3651 by Dq-soft
And here the values for point 3:

14.52.17.256 : ns=2;s=User.Float999 : 490 {System.Double} @09.11.2015 13:52:15 @@09.11.2015 13:52:16; Good
14.52.17.632 : ns=2;s=User.Float999 : 488 {System.Double} @09.11.2015 13:52:14 @@09.11.2015 13:52:14; Good
14.52.18.721 : ns=2;s=User.Float999 : 489 {System.Double} @09.11.2015 13:52:15 @@09.11.2015 13:52:15; Good

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Nov 2015 13:23 #3650 by Dq-soft
Hello

1. I use sampling-rate. This s set to the same value for all items

2.
procedure TForm2.OnMonitoredItemChanged(
  ASender: TObject;
  sender: OleVariant;
  const eventArgs: _EasyUAMonitoredItemChangedEventArgs);
var test : variant;
s,s1:String;
x,x1 : integer;
i1:longint;
begin
    inc(zaehler);
    s := formatdatetime('hh.mm.ss.zzz',now)+'  :  '+eventArgs.Arguments.NodeDescriptor.ToString;
    x := pos('Float',s)+5;
    s1 := copy(s,x,length(s)-x+1);
    x := StrToInt(s1);
    inc(anz[x],1);
    if (eventArgs.AttributeData = nil)  then
        inh[x] := inh[x] + ';'+ 'NA'
    else
    begin
        s1 :=copy(eventArgs.AttributeData.ToString,1,pos('{',
       eventArgs.AttributeData.ToString)-2);
        try
          i1 := StrToInt(s1);
        except
          i1 := -1;
        end;
        if checkbox1.checked  then
        begin
          if not( (last[x] = -1) or (last[x] = i1+1)) then
          begin
             inh[x]:=inh[x]+';'+IntToStr(last[x])+'-'+IntToStr(i1);
          end;
        end
        else
        begin
          if not( (last[x] = -1) or (last[x] = i1-1)) then
          begin
             inh[x]:=inh[x]+';'+IntToStr(last[x])+'-'+IntToStr(i1);
          end;
        end;
        last[x] := i1;
    end;
    if  copy(s,length(s)-5,6)='Float1'  then
    begin
      t2:= now-t1;
      edit1.text := formatdatetime('hh.nn.ss.zzz',t2);
      try
       if (eventArgs.AttributeData <> nil)  then
          Edit2.Text := eventArgs.AttributeData.ToString;
      finally
      end;
      t1:=Now;
    end;

3. I will test and post the values in a view minutes

4. I have tried
this code
Client := TEasyUAClient.Create(nil);
  Client.OnMonitoredItemChanged := OnMonitoredItemChanged;
  for i := 1 to 1000 do
  begin
  Client.SubscribeMonitoredItem(
    server,
    varname+inttostr(i),
    StrToInt(Edit12.Text));
    last[i] := -1;
  end;

and also this code
Client.OnMonitoredItemChanged := OnMonitoredItemChanged;
  MonitoringParameters := CoUAMonitoringParameters.Create;
  MonitoringParameters.SamplingInterval := StrToInt(Edit12.Text);
  for i := 0 to 999 do
  begin
    MonitoredItemArguments[i] := CoEasyUAMonitoredItemArguments.Create;
    MonitoredItemArguments[i].EndpointDescriptor.UrlString := server;
    MonitoredItemArguments[i].NodeDescriptor.NodeId.ExpandedText := varname+IntToStr(i+1);
    MonitoredItemArguments[i].MonitoringParameters := MonitoringParameters;
    Arguments[i] := MonitoredItemArguments[i];
    last[i] := -1;
  end;
  TVarData(HandleArray).VType := varArray or varVariant;
  TVarData(HandleArray).VArray := PVarArray(
    Client.SubscribeMultipleMonitoredItems(PSafeArray(TVarData(Arguments).VArray)));
  for I := VarArrayLowBound(HandleArray, 1) to VarArrayHighBound(HandleArray, 1) do
  begin
      Handle := Cardinal(HandleArray[I]);
  end;

The second code produced more problems tha the first one.

I have tried saplig rate 1, 500 and 1000

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Nov 2015 10:48 #3649 by support
Hello. Some additional questions:

1. Do you use the same parameters (such as sampling rate etc.) for the items? (Background: Different parameters can cause the items be placed on separate subscriptions, which could be a cause for inconsistent order).

2. Can you post here the piece of code that handles the event notifications? Specifically, I am interested in whether you would catch an unsuccessful notification indicating some kind of a problem.

3. When the values come in "wrong" order: Please obtain their ServerTimestamp and SourceTimestamp, and check their order as well, and let me know the result.

4. What sampling rate (and/or publishing rate) do you specify for the items? Ideally, can you also post the piece of code that does the Subscribe?

Thank you
Best regards

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Nov 2015 10:41 #3648 by support
From: D.
Sent: Monday, November 09, 2015 9:20 AM
To: Z.
Subject: ...

Hello,

during Testing i got a new problem:

The setting for my test :
a OPCUA Server with 1000 Float Variables (Float1 to Float1000)
a Delphi Client with your Components where all Variables are subscribed in the same way like your example, but in a vcl Form instead of a console app

If i change all variables every second ( I send 1, next second 2 then 3 ……) i have the following problem:
Some of the changed values are completely missing (the on change event didn’t fire) and some values are not in right order for example if get Value 1 then 3 then 2 then 4.

I have testes with your example Server and another server from sw toolbox with the same effect.

Is there a limit how much variables can be received via subscribing or are there some settings that can cause these problems?


With kind regards

D.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: support
Time to create page: 0.055 seconds